The Case of the $11 Margarita: Is It Legal to Withhold Menu Prices?

Many restaurants do not disclose the price of specials or cocktails on menus, hoping the impulse to imbibe will sway the customer. Restaurateurs should be aware that this practice has legal risk.

In February, 2012, the Cheesecake Factory announced that it would begin posting drink prices at its Massachusetts locations. This announcement came after a patron’s attorney threatened to sue under the Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act (MCPA) because the restaurant charged $11 for a margarita. The price for the drink had not been listed on the menu, and the server had not known the price when the patron ordered.

Is there something unique in Massachusetts? No. The MCPA is the state statute adopting the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), a model code governing the sale of goods and services. All states and the District of Columbia have similar statutes.  The UCC applies to the relationship between restaurants and customers and governs restaurants’ sale of goods, namely food and drink. The Code’s open price provisions at section 2-305 dictate what happens when the price of goods is not established upfront. Where a customer and a restaurant have not agreed on a price for a meal or drink, the restaurant is not free to set the price as it pleases, but it must charge a “reasonable price.” A jury would determine what constitutes a “reasonable price” in the event of litigation.

Practically speaking, when patrons are surprised by a bill at the end of the meal, they pay the bill and perhaps tweet their dissatisfaction. While that can cause some public relations problems, rarely, however, do they pursue legal action.

So what was different in the case of the Cheesecake Factory? The patron’s attorney had previously taken issue with pricing disclosure issues at restaurants. In July, 2011, he had started a Facebook page called “PriceMyMenu.” When his friend complained about the $11 margarita, the lawyer threatened to sue. Most likely, the Cheesecake Factory wanted to avoid any risk of a class action lawsuit in Massachusetts. Such a suit might seek double or treble damages plus attorneys’ fees. Jurors might have been outraged by an $11 margarita, especially in today’s economy.

So what lessons are there for restaurants from the case of the $11 margarita? The following preventive steps will avoid public relations and legal hassles:

  1. Update menus to list prices. This is particularly important in online and mobile applications where there is no opportunity to interact with the server before placing the order.
  2. When servers list the daily specials, they should also disclose prices.
  3. When a patron orders a custom food or beverage, have the server deliver the price information before serving the goods.
  4. Franchisors should set clear policies on pricing disclosure for all its locations and ensure its franchisees are following guidelines.

Copyright Kyle-Beth Hilfer, P.C. 2012. Kyle-Beth Hilfer is an advertising and marketing attorney and regularly advises clients on issues in pricing goods and services as well as other marketing strategies. Ms. Hilfer is of Counsel to Collen IP. To contact Ms. Hilfer, please visit her FohBoh profile or tweet her @kbhilferlaw.

Views: 535

Tags: UCC, menus, open, price, pricing, restaurants


You need to be a member of FohBoh to add comments!

Join FohBoh

Comment by Kyle-Beth Hilfer on May 2, 2012 at 10:46am

Joe, glad this is helpful. The issue requires vetting of menus and training for servers to ensure minimal risk for the restaurants.

Comment by Joe Welsh on May 2, 2012 at 9:35am

Great blog post. As we do menus for our clients we get asked this question all of the time about posting drink prices.

Comment by Kyle-Beth Hilfer on March 28, 2012 at 7:24am

Ivan, thanks for reading. You point out all the good pr reasons not to do this. I hope by clarifying the legal issues, I have shed additional light on the subject.

Comment by Ivan Collins on March 28, 2012 at 7:16am

I'm glad to see someone bring this up.  I find it really annoying that the specials tend to be super expensive and their prices seemingly left off the menu as though you shouldn't be price conscious if you want to order them.  I tend to ignore them, simply because they always leave a bad sense of sticker shock and I can't find the right time to barge in on the waiter's pitch to ask the price for each one.  I know it's an effective upsell technique or restaurants wouldn't be using it.  But it's an bad practice simply because it's not transparent.  Extracting every last dollar out of your customer in whatever way possible is not a model for success.  Embrace their budget and offer specials that help them get the most out of their dollar should be the goal. 

Comment by Kyle-Beth Hilfer on March 28, 2012 at 6:37am

Christopher, thanks for your good marketing sense. You may have seen the article on front page of today's NYT talking about how consumers know if they are getting a fair price and demand it.

Comment by Christopher Wells on March 27, 2012 at 9:21pm

Not only are they possible legal repercussions, restaurant owners need to remember that while they may make a bit more money in the short term with undisclosed prices on their menu, when the guest receives the bill they might be in for a shock.

When that happens they will most likely take their business elsewhere. As human and consumers we don't enjoy being taken for a ride, being tricked. It's not a fun feeling to feel like you've been played.: In most cases the guest will not make a scene for a few dollars, but will walk out feeling negatively about your restaurant, your brand.

Your marketing dollars are spent to bring in guests, send them home happy and ideally create repeat business with these guests. That's marketing and customer loyalty 101. When you trick them to make a few bucks on a drink you are being counterproductive. 

Transparency and honesty are the best way to build relationships with your guests. It is true that most places that don't disclose their drink prices are often hot spots for tourists. So the thinking is we might as well milk them for all we can while they are here. Wrong again. Tourist come back, the word gets around. Especially with social media the word gets around fast and comments stay online for everyone to read in the future. Don't ruin your name for the sake of a quick buck!

Be transparent and forthcoming with guest and you will always win in the end! 




Social Wine Club for Craft Wineries


Kids LiveWell atwitter over Twitter party

In its continuing effort to promote more nutritious and flavorful children's menu options, the NRA will hold a Twitter party  -More

Starbucks could become top on-premise wine seller in U.S.

Starbucks is planning to slowly expand its evening sales of wine, beer and small plates to thousands of selected stores throu -More

The evolving nature of snacks

Snacks have shifted from an after-school treat to a meal alternative as meal times become more fragmented.  -More


Posting a job or finding a job starts here at FohBoh. Call us about special $25 posting packages to syndicate across all major jobs boards.

National News

Wahlburgers Announces Expansion Plans Including Franchise Agreement in Philadelphia

Wahlburgers has signed a franchise agreement with Hingham Associates, LLC that will bring five Wahlburgers to the metropolitan Philadelphia area over the next several years. The franchise group is actively looking at sites and is targeting a late 2014-early 2015 opening for its first restaurant.

Chipotle Mexican Grill, Inc. First Quarter 2014 Revenue Up 24.4%

Comparable restaurant sales increased 13.4% - Restaurant level operating margin was 25.9%, a decrease of 40 basis points

Jamba Juice Announces Grand Opening of New St. Louis, MO Location

Jamba Juice Company announced the brand’s continued expansion in the St. Louis market with the opening of a Jamba Juice® store at 11477 Olive Blvd. on April 16, 2014.

Expert in Real Estate Analytics Joins Luna Grill

Luna Grill, the San Diego-based Mediterranean restaurant chain, is welcoming retail real estate industry veteran Greg Thorburn to its leadership team. Thorburn has been brought on board to fill the newly created position of Vice-President of Real Estate.

Rita's Italian Ice Awards Area Development Agreement for Kansas

Rita's Italian Ice has awarded franchise and area development agreements for Kansas and the Kansas City area, which extends to the Missouri side of the city, to franchisees and local residents Jay Miller, Jeff Miller and Pat Reilly.


If you are looking for capital to start or grow your restaurant, create the next 501c3, develop and launch the next app for the restaurant industry,or want to help your peers in some meaningful way, we want to know about it.


TED: Matthew Carter: My life in typefaces - Matthew Carter (2014)

Pick up a book, magazine or screen, and more than likely you'll come across some typography designed by Matthew Carter. In this charming talk, the man behind typefaces such as Verdana, Georgia and Bell Centennial (designed just for phone books -- remember them?), takes us on a spin through a career focused on the very last pixel of each letter of a font.

TED: Jeremy Kasdin: The flower-shaped starshade that might help us detect Earth-like planets - Jeremy Kasdin (2014)

Astronomers believe that every star in the galaxy has a planet, one fifth of which might harbor life. Only we haven't seen any of them -- yet. Jeremy Kasdin and his team are looking to change that with the design and engineering of an extraordinary piece of equipment: a flower petal-shaped "starshade" that allows a telescope to photograph planets from 50,000 kilometers away. It is, he says, the "coolest possible science."

TED: Norman Spack: How I help transgender teens become who they want to be - Norman Spack (2013)

Puberty is an awkward time for just about everybody, but for transgender teens it can be a nightmare, as they grow overnight into bodies they aren't comfortable with. In a heartfelt talk, endocrinologist Norman Spack tells a personal story of how he became one of the few doctors in the US to treat minors with hormone replacement therapy. By staving off the effects of puberty, Spack gives trans teens the time they need. (Filmed at TEDxBeaconStreet.)

TED: Jennifer Senior: For parents, happiness is a very high bar - Jennifer Senior (2014)

The parenting section of the bookstore is overwhelming—it's "a giant, candy-colored monument to our collective panic," as writer Jennifer Senior puts it. Why is parenthood filled with so much anxiety? Because the goal of modern, middle-class parents—to raise happy children—is so elusive. In this honest talk, she offers some kinder and more achievable aims.

© 2014   Created by FohBoh.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service