3 Keys To A Successful Digital Agency Review

Throughout my marketing career, I have participated in countless agency reviews, both as a member of agency teams as well as on the client side of the table.  Digital agency reviews, brand agencies reviews, shopper marketing agency reviews, PR agency reviews.  For as long as I can remember, the review process has been one that leaves clients exhausted, agencies frustrated, and both parties asking the question, “Is there not a better way?”.


I believe there is but it takes constraint, collaboration and commitment.


Agency: “How many agencies are participating in the review?”


Client: “We have 10 agencies presenting in 90-minute time slots over five days.”


No wonder everyone is exhausted and frustrated.  Inevitably, many people throughout any client organization have worked with a variety of agencies; everyone has “a friend in the business” or an agency that they are comfortable with. Although I respect the attempt at inclusion and collaboration to drive ownership of the agency decision throughout your organization, how can you effectively evaluate 10 different agencies?  Resist the urge.

Making it better:

  • Allow the Marketing Department to run the pitch. Sounds obvious, but it’s not always done this way. First, identify a cross-functional group (i.e. Marketing, Executive, Sales, Operations, Procurement, Finance) to participate in the review process, and then leave the final decision to the Marketing Team, as they are the group who will be working with the agency day-to-day.
  • Establish a very tight list of agency criteria (e.g. experience, work, results, geography and culture) and narrow down your list of agencies to only those that meet each of your criteria.
  • Invite no more than three agencies to pitch your business



Agency: “Can we meet with the review committee prior to the pitch?”


Client: “In addition to the information we have provided in the RFP, we will set up phone calls with the marketing team and each agency to review further questions.”


In it’s current state, the RFP and agency pitch process is not a collaborative engagement.  The client identifies a list of agencies, sends out an RFP, asks the agencies to tackle an assignment and unveil their best thinking during an in-person meeting.  Most clients do indeed share a great deal of information about their business, as well as establish times for agency Q&A prior to the formal pitch, but for the most part, the parties work very independently of each other.  But there are still a few flaws in this model.   If you are giving agencies one chance to show their best work, you have to let them behind the curtain.

Making it better:

  • If you want an agency’s best thinking, they need access – access to your web analytics, access to your front line sales teams, access to your customers, access to you. I cannot tell you how many times we changed our recommended strategies after spending time in a client’s retail channel, with a franchisee, or with their sales organization. Really great insights are not manufactured; they come from looking beyond the “what” and really understanding the “why”.
  • Spend at least one full day with each of the three agencies at their offices in a working session. Give them a topic, challenge and/or opportunity specific to your business, give them access to the data they need to prepare, and have them conduct a strategy session with your team. Let them refine the strategies and bring the outcome of this session as the assignment for the pitch. I can think of no better way to battle test their process and their people, as well as to get a chemistry check. Demand that the agency team working on your business is part of the session; and if you really want to test the chemistry , take them to dinner afterward. It’s a small investment, and although this is business, it is personal. Get to know each other before you make a decision.



Client: “It’s not fair to the other agencies for to us to spend a full day with your agency, and not with them. And we just don’t have that kind of time to spend with every agency.”


Agency: “Do you want to be fair or are you looking to find the best agency partner?”


Do both. Be fair, and, make the time to spend with each agency.  This process requires a commitment, and your executive team is relying on you to make a wise decision. You’re asking your potential agency partners to invest time and resources to present business-building ideas.  Set aside the appropriate time and resources on your end as well.

Making it better:

  • Give yourself at least 90-120 days to run a full pitch. There’s a tremendous amount of prep work that has to be done before you talk to a single agency – data gathering and formatting, identifying agency criteria, securing recommendations, finalizing a short list of agencies, writing the RFP. Agencies need time to do great work on your behalf, while also continuing to do great work for their existing clients. And you need time to evaluate them effectively.
  • Pay the agency a stipend. This doesn’t have to be much – $5k, $10k, $25k -depending on the scope of the pitch and the overall marketing spend. This is more about the gesture and the recognition of the time and resource requirements associated with the pitch. I cannot stress to you enough how far this will go in sending a message of respect and partnership to these agencies. My guess is that the agency you ultimately hire will give the money back to you (I would), and the other two will walk away feeling as if they were treated fairly.

Constraint, Collaboration, and Commitment.  A little bit of love will go along way.

Views: 88

Tags: Agencies, Agency, Digital, RFP, Review


You need to be a member of FohBoh to add comments!

Join FohBoh

Comment by John Harris on August 23, 2012 at 12:01pm

Bill:  thanks for the comment.  Goal was to show opportunities to enhance the current foundational approach vs. just throw stones.  Any agency review is such an important, and at times, overwhelming endeavor.  Hope there are some nuggets here that readers can take away and apply. 

Comment by Bill Tobin on August 23, 2012 at 9:20am

I'm not doing a digital agency review, but if I was, I would certainly follow this advice.  I especially appreciate how you show the faults in what would normally be considered sound procedure, without making anyone look stupid.  Good article John!




Social Wine Club for Craft Wineries


Casual chains aim to take menus up a few notches

Casual-dining chains including Tony Roma's, Olive Garden, Carrabba's Italian Grill and Smokey Bones are getting creative with -More

Sikkimese Turmeric and Ginger Idaho® Potatoes
Enjoy a taste of the Himalayas with these flavorful cubed Idaho® Potatoes seasoned with garlic, ginger, turmeric, coriander and chile flakes. For this and more great recipes, visit foodservice.idahopotato.com/recipes.

Crumbs debuts the Crumbnut

Cupcake chain Crumbs Bake Shop is offering the Crumbnut, a croissant-doughnut combo product, in BJ's Wholesale Clubs in addit -More

Restaurant sales rebounded in March, report says

Restaurants saw same-store sales growth of 0.7% in March, the first increase since last November, as warmer weather melted wi -More


Posting a job or finding a job starts here at FohBoh. Call us about special $25 posting packages to syndicate across all major jobs boards.

National News

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen, Inc. Announces CFO Departure in May

The company has commenced a search for Mr. Hope’s successor, reviewing both internal and external candidates. Mr. Hope will assist in the transition of duties to an interim CFO and will remain a consultant to the company through the summer.

Fuddruckers Reenters New York State With Restaurant In Middletown

introduces its first company-operated New York State site today at 340 Route 211 East in Middletown, which is located in the Hudson Valley approximately 60 miles from Manhattan.

Giardino Gourmet Salads Announces Nine Consecutive Quarters Of Positive Comparable Sales

Giardino Gourmet Salads announced that it has experienced nine consecutive quarters of positive comparable sales after posting an eight percent increase throughout the first quarter of 2014.

Organic Claims Declining on US Restaurant Menus

According to Mintel Menu Insights, while 'organic' is still the leading ethical claim on restaurant menus, its usage declined 28% between Q4 2010-13.

The Habit Burger Grill Opens Fourth Utah Location In May

The Habit Burger Grill is opening its fourth Utah location on May 1st in Sandy, Utah. The California-based restaurant known for its popular Charburgers opened its first Utah location in Sugarhouse in 2013, and has since expanded to include three more locations.


If you are looking for capital to start or grow your restaurant, create the next 501c3, develop and launch the next app for the restaurant industry,or want to help your peers in some meaningful way, we want to know about it.


TED: Jennifer Senior: For parents, happiness is a very high bar - Jennifer Senior (2014)

The parenting section of the bookstore is overwhelming—it's "a giant, candy-colored monument to our collective panic," as writer Jennifer Senior puts it. Why is parenthood filled with so much anxiety? Because the goal of modern, middle-class parents—to raise happy children—is so elusive. In this honest talk, she offers some kinder and more achievable aims.

TED: David Brooks: Should you live for your résumé ... or your eulogy? - David Brooks (2014)

Within each of us are two selves, suggests David Brooks in this meditative short talk: the self who craves success, who builds a résumé, and the self who seeks connection, community, love -- the values that make for a great eulogy. (Joseph Soloveitchik has called these selves "Adam I" and "Adam II.") Brooks asks: Can we balance these two selves?

TED: David Sengeh: The sore problem of prosthetic limbs - David Sengeh (2014)

What drove David Sengeh to create a more comfortable prosthetic limb? He grew up in Sierra Leone, and too many of the people he loves are missing limbs after the brutal civil war there. When he noticed that people who had prosthetics weren’t actually wearing them, the TED Fellow set out to discover why — and to solve the problem with his team from the MIT Media Lab.

TED: Louie Schwartzberg: Hidden miracles of the natural world - Louie Schwartzberg (2014)

We live in a world of unseeable beauty, so subtle and delicate that it is imperceptible to the human eye. To bring this invisible world to light, filmmaker Louie Schwartzberg bends the boundaries of time and space with high-speed cameras, time lapses and microscopes. At TED2014, he shares highlights from his latest project, a 3D film titled "Mysteries of the Unseen World," which slows down, speeds up, and magnifies the astonishing wonders of nature.

© 2014   Created by FohBoh.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service